Some thoughts on Plague Locusts

There have been a some posts on the "Nature of Robertson" (links will follow) about the upcoming locust plague and proposals to aerial spray the swarms.

I watched the video attached to this post on this topic and read Eris O'Brien website (and a few other things).  I then scored points for spraying and points against spraying.  To continue the sporting metaphor, realising this might annoy a few folk, this came out 7:2 against spraying (Julie from the Mallee got a red card in the first minute.)

The major score 'for' spraying came about because Eris O'Brien didn't really have an alternative, other than 'do nothing': his options about heavy rollers etc are unrealistic in most cases and are not applicable to National Parks etc.  He suggests:
  1. the plague would only last a short time, which causes me to think "Yes, animals die when they run out of food."; and 
  2. Ibises would eat the locusts - again unrealistic as there are not enough ibises for this task.
Disregarding 'spin' about cancelling the Melbourne Cup there would seem to be some serious problems for large parts of the rural communities on Western Victoria (and NSW) coming down the pipe. What I would like to see is some evidence of what would really happen if nothing was done. While I suspect no-one knows this, the references to Silent Spring in the context of massive spraying do not seem to be an excessive comment on the impact of spraying. 

In either case spending $43.5m is relatively trivial.  It is:

Comments

Denis Wilson said…
Hi Martin
Thanks for posting your opinions on Locust spraying.
Not quite sure how you got to 7:2 - but I can see you are against spraying.
Denis
3 October 2010 at 11:03:00 GMT+11
Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Insects from pine trees

Image
This afternoon (13/1/2015) we were looking out of our sunroom and noticed a strange bit of mist.  On getting my binoculars on the case I found it to be a cloud of tens of thousand of insects.  They appeared with naked eye to be flying away, but with binoculars I thought they were circling. Here are some images In the second one it may be possible to see there are two streams coming from the top of each tree. There was a loud buzzing noise but that could just be several thousand wings. Earlier in the day Frances had been to some nearby willows and they were infested with many little black soft bodied insects.  Perhaps they shifted to the pines and were swarming? Help!! Any information welcome. A colleague, from Wamboin, had noticed a similat phenomenon, but involvng eucalypts rather than pines!  Here are the photos he took with his phone. I have consulted some expert friends.   Their responses were: I would have gone for chironomids. I rec...
Read more

A tour of the West (part 1)

Image
A friend from my time in the UN sent me some photos of her family trip along Route 66.  They did this is a large camperwagon rather than a Chevy Corvette (apparently the kids jacked up about being offered a trip in the trunk).  It seems to have been a very good trip for them and most interesting to see their photos.  It was also educational for me, as I found out the German for rocking chair (schaukelstuhl, since you ask). They did 7200 miles in 30 days - a pretty serious bit of distance. This made me think of the trips we did in 1981 when living in Denver.  Frances initiated that idea by getting a book about the National Parks of the West  and marking interesting places.  I then worked out a route on a Rand-McNally Road Atlas (GPS was unknown then  - as were iPhones, personal computers and the internet).  From memory, taking nearly the whole Summer school holidays we covered about 10,000 miles in 70 days.  Here, approximately,  are ...
Read more

Maslins beach rules

Image
Anyone who was in Adelaide in the 1970s will be having a good nudge nudge at that title.  However the beach is really nice even though it is the haunt (in Summer ) of naked people.  (As an aside one of the 'van park staff was talking to some other guests and commented that the sights on the beach in Summer were not at all exciting.)  In April it is the haunt of seniors, many of them exercising their dogs, and thus a far more attractive place. Getting to the beach was a walk of about 1km along roads, from our van.  The second half of this went past a rather daggy looking paddock with many formed ridges in it, as though it was irrigated, although a water sources wasn't evident.  The paddock got interesting towards the end as some green parrots appeared.  Thanks to Frances eye for detail we have subsequently identified these as Elegant Parrots: my first lifer for 2014.    The locale is indicated by the red lines in this mudmap: Here are the bird...
Read more