Pom and Australian elections

The investigation reported below arose through a discussion of voting systems and a question being asked about the number of candidates per constituency in the UK (with first past the post).

I initially contacted the UP Elections Commission.  They didn't have information about the number of candidates per constituency but gave me a link to the UK House of Commons Library (HOCL) who publish a mass of data online.  After a bit of fiddling I found a useful briefing which has the number of candidates for each constituency for all general elections since 1918.

The basic data from that shows the following for 2019:

Chorley is the seat with 2: this is the current Speaker's seat and by convention he stands as an independent and is usually unopposed.  In 2019 the Greens broke with convention (how unusual) and ran against him.

The seat with 8 candidates was Strangford in Northern Ireland.  This has a full array of the Irish parties (including NI Conservatives in the Wiki, which HOCL list as simply Conservative) and UKIP which is not listed by HOCL as a party: presumably these folk stayed as UKIP being flat out brownshirts rather than simply being Brexit (which was a Party).

A small amount of complexity was added by the use of an "other" code by HOCL.  This is quite reasonable since in some cases there are 2 independents (and the independent in seat A will probably be nothing to do with the independent in seat B).  335 seats (out of 650) have some votes (minimum 58, maximum - Chorley - 36270) for 'other'.  I have checked out some of the seats in Wikipedia to find out the affiliations of all the candidates, and thus gain a feeling for how well the distribution above matches the actual number of candidates.  

My feeling - which with $5 will buy you a cup of coffee - is that in the significant majority of cases 'Other' represents a single candidate, typically running as an Independent.  I came across a few examples of Other = 3 candidates and a somewhat larger number of Other =2.  So I think the distribution is pretty reasonable.  Perhaps someone with contacts in the Australian Electoral System (or the Parliamentary Library) can comment on the number of candidates per seat in Australia?  Some commentary on selected UK seats is below.

Selected seats with a high turnout for 'other'.

East Devon: (26,144 votes for Other) 2 Independents one of whom is a popular County Councillor and regular candidate. 2019 #candidates 6.

Beaconsfield: 2 Independents one of whom was a former MP suspended from the Conservative Party 2019 #candidates 5.

SW Hertfordshire: the former MP was not preselected so ran as the independent.  2019 #candidates 5.

Ashfield: a local Government politician ran as the independent.  2019 #candidates 5.

Belfast West. 2 independents one of whom is a local politician 2019 #candidates 6.

Birkenhead: former Labour member ran as the independent 2019 #candidates 6.

Selected seats with a Moderate turnout for 'other'

South Basildon and East Thurrock 1 independent 2019 #candidates 4.

Pontypridd 3 independents 2019 #candidates 7.

Runnymede and Weybridge 2 Independents and 1 UKIP (not listed as a Party, presumably as most of them ran as Brexit) 2019 #candidates 7.

South Suffolk: 1 independent (originally ran as Brexit, but changed his mind!) 2019 #candidates 5.

Mole Valley: how could one keep a straight face with a constituency called that! 2 Others, 1 independent and 1 UKIP see above. 2019 #candidates 6

Selected seats with a Low turnout for 'other'

East Hampshire 2 for very small 'parties'. 2019 #candidates 6

West Dunbartonshire 1 Independent. 2019 #candidates 6

Harwich and North_Essex 2 Independents.  2019 #candidates 6

Other matters

The information from HOCL also enables me to calculate the number of seats (421 of 650) in which the first past the post did so with a majority (in other words would also have won under a preferential system).  

It is impossible to predict exactly what would have happened in the remaining cases as the voting systems are so different.  However only 20 seats were won with <40% of the vote.  I suspect that even under an Australian system there would probably be enough leakage to the winner from lower placed candidates to the winner to keep the result the same where someone got 40% of the vote.

Possibly of more importance than the voting system is the turnout.  Here is the % turnout from HOCL.
In 600 of the seats turn out was less than 75% and in 215 seats less than 65%.  And this is a system where party workers doorknock in the afternoons to encourage people to vote and/or give them a lift to the booth.  (Or at least they used to in the 1960s.)   No wonder they end up with the crap governments they do!!

After I published this to a Facebook discussion I was given data showing the number of candidates (technically 'nominations') for each constituency (technically 'Division') in Australia.  The comparison is interesting (but I am not sure what it means for the outcome).   

The Poms do not elect their Upper House so I can't compare the bed-sheet Senate voting papers from Australia with what the UK might come up with.



Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Insects from pine trees

Image
This afternoon (13/1/2015) we were looking out of our sunroom and noticed a strange bit of mist.  On getting my binoculars on the case I found it to be a cloud of tens of thousand of insects.  They appeared with naked eye to be flying away, but with binoculars I thought they were circling. Here are some images In the second one it may be possible to see there are two streams coming from the top of each tree. There was a loud buzzing noise but that could just be several thousand wings. Earlier in the day Frances had been to some nearby willows and they were infested with many little black soft bodied insects.  Perhaps they shifted to the pines and were swarming? Help!! Any information welcome. A colleague, from Wamboin, had noticed a similat phenomenon, but involvng eucalypts rather than pines!  Here are the photos he took with his phone. I have consulted some expert friends.   Their responses were: I would have gone for chironomids. I rec...
Read more

A tour of the West (part 1)

Image
A friend from my time in the UN sent me some photos of her family trip along Route 66.  They did this is a large camperwagon rather than a Chevy Corvette (apparently the kids jacked up about being offered a trip in the trunk).  It seems to have been a very good trip for them and most interesting to see their photos.  It was also educational for me, as I found out the German for rocking chair (schaukelstuhl, since you ask). They did 7200 miles in 30 days - a pretty serious bit of distance. This made me think of the trips we did in 1981 when living in Denver.  Frances initiated that idea by getting a book about the National Parks of the West  and marking interesting places.  I then worked out a route on a Rand-McNally Road Atlas (GPS was unknown then  - as were iPhones, personal computers and the internet).  From memory, taking nearly the whole Summer school holidays we covered about 10,000 miles in 70 days.  Here, approximately,  are ...
Read more

Maslins beach rules

Image
Anyone who was in Adelaide in the 1970s will be having a good nudge nudge at that title.  However the beach is really nice even though it is the haunt (in Summer ) of naked people.  (As an aside one of the 'van park staff was talking to some other guests and commented that the sights on the beach in Summer were not at all exciting.)  In April it is the haunt of seniors, many of them exercising their dogs, and thus a far more attractive place. Getting to the beach was a walk of about 1km along roads, from our van.  The second half of this went past a rather daggy looking paddock with many formed ridges in it, as though it was irrigated, although a water sources wasn't evident.  The paddock got interesting towards the end as some green parrots appeared.  Thanks to Frances eye for detail we have subsequently identified these as Elegant Parrots: my first lifer for 2014.    The locale is indicated by the red lines in this mudmap: Here are the bird...
Read more